feat(plugins): Given an optional plugin, conditionally discard deps (#947)

* deps_of_all_optional: First, refactor the code responsible for disabling unneeded deps to be more generic

* deps_of_all_optional: Second, also disable unneeded deps from plugins marked as all optional

* deps_of_all_optional: add tests proving unneeded optional deps are now also discarded

* deps_of_all_optional: forgot return type

---------

Co-authored-by: abeldekat <abel@nomail.com>

lua/lazy/core/plugin.lua

@@ -146,6 +146,31 @@ function Spec:warn(msg)
   self:log(msg, vim.log.levels.WARN)
 end
 
+---@param gathered_deps string[]
+---@param dep_of table<string,string[]>
+---@param on_disable fun(string):nil
+function Spec:fix_dependencies(gathered_deps, dep_of, on_disable)
+  local function should_disable(dep_name)
+    for _, parent in ipairs(dep_of[dep_name] or {}) do
+      if self.plugins[parent] then
+        return false
+      end
+    end
+    return true
+  end
+
+  for _, dep_name in ipairs(gathered_deps) do
+    -- only check if the plugin is still enabled and it is a dep
+    if self.plugins[dep_name] and self.plugins[dep_name]._.dep then
+      -- check if the dep is still used by another plugin
+      if should_disable(dep_name) then
+        -- disable the dep when no longer needed
+        on_disable(dep_name)
+      end
+    end
+  end
+end
+
 function Spec:fix_cond()
   for _, plugin in pairs(self.plugins) do
     local cond = plugin.cond
@@ -159,7 +184,9 @@ function Spec:fix_cond()
   end
 end
 
+---@return string[]
 function Spec:fix_optional()
+  local all_optional_deps = {}
   if not self.optional then
     ---@param plugin LazyPlugin
     local function all_optional(plugin)
@@ -170,9 +197,13 @@ function Spec:fix_optional()
     for _, plugin in pairs(self.plugins) do
       if plugin.optional and all_optional(plugin) then
         self.plugins[plugin.name] = nil
+        if plugin.dependencies then
+          vim.list_extend(all_optional_deps, plugin.dependencies)
         end
       end
     end
+  end
+  return all_optional_deps
 end
 
 function Spec:fix_disabled()
@@ -183,15 +214,16 @@ function Spec:fix_disabled()
     end
   end
 
-  self:fix_optional()
-  self:fix_cond()
-
   ---@type table<string,string[]> plugin to parent plugin
   local dep_of = {}
 
   ---@type string[] dependencies of disabled plugins
   local disabled_deps = {}
 
+  ---@type string[] dependencies of plugins that are completely optional
+  local all_optional_deps = self:fix_optional()
+  self:fix_cond()
+
   for _, plugin in pairs(self.plugins) do
     local enabled = not (plugin.enabled == false or (type(plugin.enabled) == "function" and not plugin.enabled()))
     if enabled then
@@ -209,27 +241,17 @@ function Spec:fix_disabled()
     end
   end
 
-  -- check deps of disabled plugins
+  -- fix deps of plugins that are completely optional
-  for _, dep in ipairs(disabled_deps) do
+  self:fix_dependencies(all_optional_deps, dep_of, function(dep_name)
-    -- only check if the plugin is still enabled and it is a dep
+    self.plugins[dep_name] = nil
-    if self.plugins[dep] and self.plugins[dep]._.dep then
+  end)
-      -- check if the dep is still used by another plugin
+  -- fix deps of disabled plugins
-      local keep = false
+  self:fix_dependencies(disabled_deps, dep_of, function(dep_name)
-      for _, parent in ipairs(dep_of[dep] or {}) do
+    local plugin = self.plugins[dep_name]
-        if self.plugins[parent] then
-          keep = true
-          break
-        end
-      end
-      -- disable the dep when no longer needed
-      if not keep then
-        local plugin = self.plugins[dep]
     plugin._.kind = "disabled"
     self.plugins[plugin.name] = nil
     self.disabled[plugin.name] = plugin
-      end
+  end)
-    end
-  end
 end
 
 ---@param msg string

tests/core/plugin_spec.lua

@@ -273,6 +273,25 @@ describe("plugin spec opt", function()
       end
     end
   end)
+
+  it("handles the optional keyword", function()
+    local tests = {
+      [{ { "foo/bax" }, { "foo/bar", optional = true, dependencies = "foo/dep1" } }] = false,
+      [{ { "foo/bax", dependencies = "foo/dep1" }, { "foo/bar", optional = true, dependencies = "foo/dep1" } }] = true,
+    }
+    for test, ret in pairs(tests) do
+      local spec = Plugin.Spec.new(test)
+      assert(#spec.notifs == 0)
+      assert(spec.plugins.bax)
+      assert(not spec.plugins.bar)
+      assert(#spec.disabled == 0)
+      if ret then
+        assert(spec.plugins.dep1)
+      else
+        assert(not spec.plugins.opt1)
+      end
+    end
+  end)
 end)
 
 describe("plugin opts", function()